Accessible Vans
The Ins and Outs of Getting Out and About
by Bill Greenberg
Paiman Komeilizadeh of San Jose, Calif., is both intelligent and ambitious. He
holds a bachelor's degree in business administration, with a minor in
accounting, and has completed extensive coursework in computer programming and
applications — all of which he hopes will help him realize his dream of
building a successful business.
He's also affected by spinal muscular atrophy, and uses a power wheelchair.
These days Komeilizadeh is president of ResourceHunt.com, an online
clearinghouse that seeks to provide one-stop shopping for products and services
assisting people with disabilities.
Like anyone seeking to start a new business, Komeilizadeh had to develop a
business plan, research his intended market and obtain financing. He also
negotiates with manufacturers, wholesalers and retailers.
In other words, he attends a lot of meetings.
"If I didn't have my van, I wouldn't be able to run my own business," he says,
talking about his converted 1998 Ford F-150 van. "There are so many
appointments, so many things that have to happen right this minute, that you
need that transportation, that mobility."
When he worked as an accountant, Komeilizadeh relied on California's Outreach
program,"which is like a taxi service for people with disabilities," he
reports. "I could get same-day service, but it usually took two to three hours
to get someone out to me, and two to three hours to get back. So by then the
whole day is gone."
Not only that, but waiting for a ride makes punctuality almost impossible.
"When I had to meet with a bank's financial people, they had to wait about an
hour and 45 minutes for me to get there," he recalls. "And that was very, very
awkward."
|
Where Would You Like to Go Today? |
So you'd like to be able to get out of your house, visit friends and family, run
errands or even get a job. You've looked into your public transportation
options, and you've concluded that what you really need is the flexibility and
independence that come with having your own vehicle.
You're not alone. According to a 2000 National Organization on Disability/Harris
survey of Americans with disabilities,
|
| Mary Coletti chose the accessible Companion Seat, by Braun Corp., which she transfers into before getting into the van. |
|
people with severe disabilities are three times as likely as those
without disabilities to think transportation is a problem, and twice as likely
as people with slight disabilities. The survey found that people with
disabilities spend an average of 5.7 hours away from home each day.
The most recent estimate from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
(NHTSA) suggests that there are some 383,000 adapted vehicles on the road these
days. So the good news is that you can have your own wheels. Like anything
else, however, it's going to take some effort.
|
Who's Driving This Thing, You or Me? |
|
The first decision that needs to be made is: Who's going to drive? If your
spouse or caregiver will do the driving, the process is relatively simple. The
only adaptive equipment you'll need to arrange is whatever it takes to get you
into the vehicle and keep you secure while the vehicle is moving.
Mary Coletti of Nottingham, Pa., is quite comfortable leaving the driving chores
for her husband, Sergio. About a year ago, Coletti purchased a 2000 Dodge Grand
Caravan SE minivan from a local Vantage Mobility International dealer ("Resources").
Coletti has SMA and uses either a manual wheelchair or a three-wheeled scooter.
"The reason we bought it is because if, somewhere down the line, I get worse
than I am right now, we're set," she explains. "We have the van."
Coletti's van features a 10-inch dropped floor (for greater headroom), an
electric door and an under-vehicle lift ramp. The van's suspension allows the
vehicle to "kneel" — meaning it lowers 4 to 6 inches, thus enabling easier
access via the ramp.
For the passenger seat, the VMI dealer offered Coletti a choice between a
"transfer" seat and a "companion" seat.
"A transfer seat is [used] if you want to roll in, get up and transfer," she
explains. "But I'm 5-foot-9 and my husband is just a little bit taller than I
am. And when he tried, he couldn't stand up straight in the van. I can't be
hunched over, or else I'd probably fall on my face."
Instead, Coletti opted for the companion seat. With this seat, you simply open
the front passenger door and flip a switch. The seat automatically extends out
of the vehicle, rotates 90 degrees and lowers.
Coletti then, while on the ground, transfers from her wheelchair into the seat,
and — with Sergio helping her swing her legs and feet — the chair lifts her up
and into the van. He then stows her scooter or wheelchair in the back behind
the front seats — and they're off.
"I just got right up and right in," she says. "It was very interesting, actually
having a seat lift you up and put you inside, because I can't step onto
anything. I can't even go up steps, because I have my weakness from my hips to
my feet."
Among companies that make companion seats is Bruno Independent Living Aids,
whose seat is called the Turny.
Van shoppers must also decide between rear-entry and side-entry models.
Viewpoint Mobility of Kalamazoo, Mich., touts the ease and convenience of its
rear-entry system, the Vision. You might consider this option if your garage or
carport is too narrow to comfortably allow you to enter through the side.
Proponents also point to the ease of entry from the back of the van — pulling
straight into position, as opposed to having to make a sharp 90-degree turn as
soon as you get in the vehicle.
Side-entry proponents, on the other hand, argue that that system dramatically
increases seating and storage space. It also avoids the potential hazard of
exiting a vehicle from the rear, particularly in a crowded parking lot.
The correct choice depends on your taste, preference and unique needs.
|
It's the Chauffeur's Day Off |
|
According to NHTSA, the most popular adaptive modification made to vehicles is
the conversion to hand controls. Here's where the choices become a good deal
more complicated, and often a lot more expensive.
"There are so many different configurations," Richard Gatewood of Versailles,
Ky., president of Wheelchair Getaways, says. "For someone to drive from a
wheelchair, that requires a pretty intense conversion that has to do with the
specific disabilities of the individual."
It also requires a power lockdown that's specific to your wheelchair.
Paiman Komeilizadeh estimates the total cost of his 1998 Ford F-150, complete
with state-of-the-art Scott System modification, at roughly $100,000.
|
| Paiman Komeilizadeh demonstrates his state-of-the-art Scott System hand controls. |
For that kind of money, you'd expect Komeilizadeh's van to have all the
"bells and whistles," right?
"No, it doesn't," he says. "But it does allow me to drive."
Manufactured by driving Systems inc. (dSi) of Van Nuys, Calif., the Scott System
provides quadriplegic drivers with steering, accelerator and brake systems, all
controllable with one hand.
"They really did a marvelous job on this — it's unbelievable," he says. "For
example, the steering wheel is a gas pedal and a brake, at the same time.
Shifting the gears is just pushing a button. They also rerouted every
electronic thing you have to reach into a single box, and they located the box
where I can reach it."
On the other end of the spectrum, Automobility Manufacturing of Saskatchewan,
Canada, offers a hand-control system that can be attached to any vehicle with
very little effort. Its 901 System can be installed without modifying the
vehicle in any way, allowing others to drive as well.
|
Now Might Be a Good Time to Ask for Directions |
|
"Driving is viewed not as just a 'privilege' but as a necessity. When a
disability occurs, it can affect the skills necessary for driving." So says the
Association for Driver Rehabilitation Specialists (ADED). Founded in 1977, this
nonprofit organization currently boasts a membership of some 270 certified
driver rehabilitation specialists (CDRS) in the United States and Canada.
Susan Pierce is a CDRS and occupational therapist in Orlando, Fla. With 21
years' experience under her belt, she understands the importance of mobility to
someone with a disability.
"You can't put a value on that kind of independence," she says simply. "Whether
it costs a hundred or a million dollars, to that person it's worth everything."
A CDRS can help you determine whether you'd be able to drive with modifications,
and what kind of vehicle would be best for you. Before consulting this
specialist (see the ADED listing in "Resources"),
you'll need to obtain a doctor's prescription giving medical approval for your
initial evaluation.
"The first thing I'm going to do is sit down and talk with you about your
disease process, and how it affects your strength and functional abilities,"
Pierce explains. This comprehensive evaluation addresses everything from
physical capabilities and visual acuity to an assessment of your
visual-perceptual-cognitive abilities. From there, the CDRS can determine the
appropriate vehicle for your next test — the driving assessment.
"We do a moving assessment, first looking at their physical abilities to see if
they need any adaptive equipment for driving," Pierce continues. "If they
don't, then we would carry on with the road test, progressing them into traffic
and planning a route that might bring out any deficits that we think the person
might have.
"If they do require driving equipment, then we have to do that assessment, train
them on that equipment, and then do the road test."
After this multistage evaluation process — and after determining that you can
drive — the CDRS can recommend a vehicle type, adaptive equipment and local
vendors.
"We give them a prescription for their adaptive equipment or vehicle
modifications, which can be used to obtain quotes from qualified vendors,"
Pierce says.
After you've purchased a vehicle, the CDRS will do a final vehicle inspection
and fitting. "We meet the client at the vendor's shop and inspect the vehicle
inside and out," Pierce says. "Then we put the client in the vehicle and fit it
for them." In fact, the CDRS will remain in the picture until both of you are
satisfied that you can operate your vehicle safely.
Pierce says that "by going through the process, you don't waste any money buying
a vehicle that ends up not working for you. And you don't waste money on very
expensive driving equipment that maybe you didn't need, or is too much for
you."
Driving specialists like Pierce also know about potential funding sources that
might be able to help you purchase a van, such as the state's Vocational
Rehabilitation program, the Veterans Administration or dealer programs.
These resources may also help with the CDRS's fee, which can range from $375 to
$1,200.
|
Better Buckle Up, This Ride Is Going to Get Bumpy |
Wheelchair Getaways' Gatewood recommends that you proceed very cautiously during
the buying process.
"It's quite an investment to get into one of these vehicles — somewhere between
$34,000 and $42,000 to get into a full-size van or minivan that's just
basically outfitted."
And "just basically outfitted" generally doesn't mean hand controls. Adding
modifications for drivers can push the cost up to as much as $70,000 — or even
beyond that, as in Komeilizadeh's case.
If you've decided to strike out on your own and handle the buying decision
yourself, Pamela Bankston has one word of advice:
"Research," says the Prescott, Wis., woman, who just purchased a full-size van
for transporting her husband, Ed, who is affected by inclusion-body myositis
(IBM). The Bankstons' van was obtained from Associated Rollx, headquartered in
the nearby Twin Cities area of Minnesota. "Don't walk in and just see one or
two people."
Bankston started her research on the Internet. "The Internet is a fabulous
source to find [dealers] all over the country, and to ask questions of people
other than in your area."
It was a time-consuming process, she admits, "but I do that for everything, so
that wasn't unusual for us. Once you have a family member who has a rare
disease like this, you become an expert," she adds.
|
| In Lionel Oubre's IMS Ramp Van system, the van kneels, the sliding door opens electronically and the ramp unfolds automatically. |
"I majored in art, but guess what? I know a lot more about this other
stuff than I ever thought I knew about art."
Lionel Oubre of New Iberia, La., agrees. He recently purchased a 2000 Dodge
Grand Caravan ES minivan from his local Independent Mobility Systems (IMS)
dealer, after countless hours of research.
"What I did was get on the Internet and use a search engine," he explains. "I
typed in 'vehicles for the handicapped' and I got all kinds of stuff. You start
poking around and eventually you find what you're looking for."
|
What Are We Going to Do When It Breaks Down? |
|
You know it's going to happen sooner or later — something is going to go wrong.
So before you invest tens of thousands of dollars in your new vehicle, you need
to figure out who will take care of service — everything from regular
maintenance to warranty work and repairs.
One of Oubre's previous vehicles was serviced by a dealer located in
not-so-nearby New Orleans. "That's a three-hour drive each way, which kills
your whole day," he laments. "You go all that way, and then maybe they don't
have the part in stock. So you go back home and do it all over again the next
day."
The National Mobility Equipment Dealers Association (NMEDA) is a good place to
start your search for a reputable dealership or service center. NMEDA has
established detailed guidelines on proper installation and service of mobility
equipment for people with disabilities, and member dealerships are committed to
upholding those standards. Going to an NMEDA dealer or service shop can be a
good way to guard against potential unscrupulous businesses that may attempt to
take advantage of customers with disabilities.
|
| This IMS Ramp Van is a converted 2000 Dodge Caravan Sport SE minivan. The hand control system is the EGB-SS, by Electronic Mobility Controls, of Baton Rouge, La., and the E-Z Lock by Mobility Systems (foreground) holds the wheelchair in place. |
NMEDA will refer you to a dealer such as French Floyd, the owner of Sylacauga
Handicap of Sylacauga, Ala. (near Birmingham). Floyd's business displays
NMEDA's coveted five-star rating, and submits to NMEDA audits twice a year to
maintain that rating. Floyd not only sells new vans, but he can also do custom
installations and modifications, as well as provide service for Braun and IMS
equipment.
"We're a member of Adaptive Alliance also," Floyd says. "We do anything anybody
needs for handicapped driving."
Floyd takes his work seriously, probably because he's affected by limb-girdle
muscular dystrophy, and uses a power wheelchair and an adapted Chrysler minivan
to maintain his own mobility.
"I know how important it is to be able to go out and be able to drive," he says.
"I would encourage people, if they are capable of driving, to pursue it, to go
after it."
Twenty years ago, Floyd had to travel to Lakeland, Fla., to get his first van.
"That's what got me in the business," he recalls. "I was going from walking to
crawling to not being able to get in and out of the car. Then I gave up my job,
went home and sat down, and didn't feel like I was going to be able to do
anything again. But I got me a power chair, and I got me a van I could drive,
and that changed my world and my thinking to where I could get out here and
help people."
Now, he adds, "The industry's getting strong, and it's important that you get a
vehicle that's equipped right."
|
It's Going to Cost HOW MUCH? |
|
You've found the van of your dreams, and you know exactly what modifications you
need. You even know who's going to fix it when it breaks.
Now all you have to figure out is how to pay for your van.
Here's one area in which a certified driver rehab specialist can help. But if
you're determined to do it on your own, here are a couple of suggestions.
The $100,000 cost of Komeilizadeh's van was picked up by the California
Department of Vocational Rehabilitation, but it took him roughly five years to
get through the whole process. Vocational Rehabilitation programs vary from
state to state, but most rely on federal government funding and thus have to
comply with the federal standard, which mandates coverage of the transportation
needed by an individual to achieve employment.
Voc Rehab can also help you adapt a van. But Komeilizadeh cautions not to expect
the agency to say yes the first time you ask.
"You really have to be self-confident, and know how you have to go forward with
these things," he advises. "Persistence is everything."
While Oubre arranged financing for his minivan himself, the Veterans
Administration paid his local dealer for the adaptive equipment and
installation — though it took the VA four to five months to process the
relevant paperwork. Oubre is a veteran with a service-connected disability in
addition to his limb-girdle MD.
"Getting the vehicle itself was the easy part," Oubre says.
Some commercial banks have agreed to extend the finance period for adapted vans
to 10 years, in an effort to make the monthly payments more palatable to
consumers. In addition, several major vehicle manufacturers have financial
assistance programs or rebates geared to customers who have disabilities.
Recent figures from the U.S. Census Bureau indicate that people with
disabilities influence more than $770 billion of the $3 trillion in annual
consumer spending. Which means that you, as a consumer, have a lot more clout
in the marketplace than you might have thought.
|
Be an Informed Consumer — Not a Captive Consumer |
|
So before you buy, do your homework. Talk to as many people as possible, and
make sure you've received answers to all your questions — and that those
answers make sense to you.
"There is always a way to do anything," Komeilizadeh says. "Believe in yourself
and be persistent. You know what you want — go get it!"  |
|