Simply Stated... Clinical Trials |
As progress toward treatment grows, keeping track of clinical trials in
neuromuscular diseases has become more important — and more daunting — than
ever. These days, it's fairly easy to find scientific reports about clinical
trials, but wading through the technical jargon in those reports can be
difficult.
If you're considering enrolling in a clinical trial, you'll probably want to
understand the trial's design and purpose. To make it easier, we've put
together this list of common concepts and terms that describe how clinical
trials are set up and analyzed.
TREATMENT VS. CONTROL GROUPS
Clinical trials are studies done in humans to evaluate potential medical
treatments, such as drugs and devices, or techniques, from physical therapy to
stem cell transplantation. By a loose definition, studies that examine one
group of people before and after treatment could be considered clinical trials.
But by the strictest definition, a clinical trial compares a group of people
receiving the experimental treatment, the treatment group, to a similar
group of people who don't receive the treatment, the control group.
Usually, the control group is given an inert substance called a placebo,
so that any expectations participants may have about the experimental treatment
will be the same in both groups and therefore theoretically won't influence the
results. When the trial is finished, health differences between the two groups
can be attributed to the treatment being tried instead of other factors, such
as the natural course of a disease, positive expectations of a drug's effects,
age or gender of the participants, and so forth.
Crossover Trial Design
Sometimes, midway through the trial, the group receiving the treatment switches
to the placebo, and vice versa, with neither group knowing which substance is
which. This crossover is done to address ethical concerns about depriving one
group of a possibly beneficial treatment for the duration of the trial.
Crossover trial designs encourage trial participation by promising all
participants access to the experimental treatment for half the trial's
duration.
Open-Label Trial Design
In an open-label trial, everyone involved "sees the label" on the drug container
and knows what he's taking. In this trial, there's no placebo group.
Single- & Double-Blinded
In a single-blinded trial, the participants don't know whether they're receiving
a treatment or placebo until the trial is over. In a double-blinded trial,
neither the participants nor the researchers know who's receiving
treatment or placebo until the trial is over.
Both of these designs are meant to eliminate expectations that could bias the
trial results. Placebo-controlled, double-blinded trials are the gold standard
of clinical trials.
PHASES
When reading about a clinical trial, it's important to recognize the trial's
goals. Of course, the ultimate goal of clinical trials is to develop effective
treatments for disease, but it's also important to uphold the physician's oath,
"First, do no harm."
Trials usually take place in phases that move from ensuring safety to
proving efficacy.
Phase 1 trials are designed primarily to evaluate the safety of an experimental
treatment, given at a small dose. They're also used to smooth out potential
problems in how the treatment is administered; for example, they can reveal
whether or not a drug has access to the right cells in the body, and whether
the drug triggers desired changes in those cells.
A phase 1 trial usually focuses on a small number of participants, sometimes
healthy volunteers.
Phase 2 trials are meant to test safety and therapeutic efficacy, and usually
involve an escalation of the treatment dose. The number of participants
increases and is limited to people who have the disease under study.
Phase 3 trials are large-scale trials designed to establish the final word on
therapeutic efficacy. Sometimes, a range of treatment doses is investigated to
identify the optimal dosage. If the treatment proves beneficial, its developers
will ask the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for permission to market it.
TRIAL RESULTS
How do researchers use clinical trial data to determine whether a treatment is
safe and effective? Ideally, they use statistical methods to determine if the
treatment caused a difference between the control group and the treatment
group.
Measures and Means
Long before a clinical trial begins, researchers select one or more outcome
measures or endpoints as indicators of the treatment's effects.
For neuromuscular diseases, common outcome measures are muscle strength,
quality of life and survival. Once the trial has stopped, the researchers
compare the average (or mean) outcome measure in the treatment
group to that in the control group.
A significant difference between the outcomes of the treatment group and the
control group is taken as evidence that the treatment had some effect. To
statisticians, "significant" doesn't mean "important"; it means that it's
unlikely the difference could have occurred by chance. The numerical measure of
significance is called the p-value.
Significance Levels
Statisticians and researchers recognize two standard cutoffs for a significant
difference — the .01 (1 percent) and .05 (5 percent) significance levels. A
p-value below one of these levels means the difference would have been observed
by chance less than 1 percent of the time, or less than 5 percent of the time.
Although p-values are arguably the most important data in a scientific study,
they're reported in parentheses, like this: (p < .01), meaning the p-value
is less than 1 percent.  |