|
QUEST Volume 8, Number 3, June 2001
by Margaret Wahl
It's the kind of thing you think can never happen to you — until it does. Your
baby is born with a life-threatening condition that fascinates but puzzles
pediatric specialists, while it terrifies you and turns your family's life
inside out.
Often such surprises come without warning. There's no family history of any such
disorder, and prenatal tests have revealed no serious problems.
The first few weeks leave parents exhausted, uncertain whether their baby will
live, and praying they'll make the right choices.
Monette Smith makes eye contact with Christian
while his eyes are taped open. The tape is used at intervals during the day to
compensate for his weak eye-opening muscles.
Photos by Karen Dickey
|
If the baby survives the first few weeks, a whole new set of questions arises:
How will we afford to care for this baby? What will our insurance cover? How
can we manage all this complex equipment?
And then there are the long-term questions: If the child survives, what will
life be like? Will he walk? Talk? Play? Read?
There are often unresolved diagnostic issues, since muscle biopsies and other
tests can be hard to interpret in infants.
Yet, with it all, there can be unexpected rewards in caring for critically ill
babies. And some children go on to survive and thrive despite dire predictions.
'EVERY TEST YOU CAN IMAGINE'
Albert and Monette Smith of Round Rock, Texas, knew all wasn't well with their
second child even before he was born. Two sonograms had revealed that the
baby's feet were fixed in an abnormal position and that fetal movements were
less frequent than normal.
But they weren't prepared for the days that would follow Christian's birth on
Nov. 6, 1999. He was born floppy, unresponsive and with very weak breathing.
Doctors told the Smiths their son might be severely mentally retarded as well
as physically impaired, but Monette didn't believe it. Christian, she says,
"seemed to know who his mother was, that I was there," even in the first days
of his fragile life.
During Christian's first weeks in the neonatal intensive care unit at a hospital
in Austin, Texas, the tiny baby was subjected to "every single test you can
imagine," Monette recalls. Doctors ordered brain and spinal MRI scans,
metabolic workups, urine and stool examinations, a search for botulism. Nothing
was conclusive.
Finally, with a confusing muscle biopsy picture, specialists concluded that
Christian had type 1 spinal muscular atrophy, even though a DNA test for that
disease had been negative. In SMA, muscle-controlling nerve cells in the spinal
cord fail to function, leading to profound weakness of the muscles, including
those controlling breathing. Children with type 1 SMA usually die before age 2.
'CALGON, TAKE ME AWAY'
Christian's disorder, whatever it was, affected his muscle tone, breathing and
swallowing. His stomach couldn't keep liquids from coming back up through his
esophagus and potentially into his lungs, a condition known as
gastro-esophageal reflux.
To protect the baby's airway, doctors performed surgery to wrap the upper part
of his stomach around the lower part of his esophagus (fundoplication). They
also created a sealable opening into Christian's stomach through which formula
could be given via a gastrostomy tube. Delivering food into his stomach
bypasses the weak upper airway muscles that could allow food or liquids to get
into the lungs and cause infection or choking.
The Smiths were in shock. "When you have a child, you're worried about getting
up at night, about diapers and formula," Monette says. "You're not thinking
about life and death decisions. Your whole world has just crashed around you.
You feel so out of place. It was like, 'Calgon, take me away.' How did I get
here? I don't want to be here."
But there was no escaping the truth. Christian might not survive in the long
term, and in the short term, his care would take an almost unthinkable amount
of time, effort and money.
ROOMING IN, FREAKING OUT
Some weeks after Christian's birth, Monette and Albert took advantage of the
hospital's rooming-in plan. They stayed with Christian for a weekend while
learning how to take care of him and manage all his special equipment, with
professional staff nearby to help in an emergency.
Christian needs to have saliva and mucus
suctioned out of his upper airway several times an hour.
|
At the end of the weekend, they were exhausted. Neither had gotten any sleep,
with monitor alarms going off all night and Christian needing to have
secretions suctioned out of his airway many times an hour.
It was becoming clear that one of them, probably Monette, would have to stop
working and take care of Christian 24 hours a day (along with their older
child, Corbin, then 2). At the time, Monette was making $30,000 a year as an
accountant, and Albert was making $34,000 in the information technology
department of a large computer manufacturer. With the loss of Monette's income,
the family would probably have to sell their home and cars to pay the medical
bills. Nursing care, even just for a night shift, would cost some $64,000 a
year. But, without it, how could Monette stay up all night and take care of
Christian during the day?
The Smiths learned that 24-hour nursing care for Christian, for which their
insurance companies denied coverage, would cost $192,720 a year — hardly
affordable. Yet, with nursing care, they believed they could keep their jobs
and somehow manage to pay for everything else on their list, which grew longer
every day.
The list was full of unpleasant surprises. They'd have to pay for the formula
Christian takes in through his tube. It cost $38 a case and the baby went
through about a case every week and a half. Christian's equipment needs
included an oximeter, a device that measures oxygen through the skin using a
probe that clips to a finger or toe. The Smiths' insurance would cover one
probe a month. But a probe doesn't last a month, and the Smiths have to replace
them at $120 each.
Disposable medical supplies such as sterile gloves, tape, syringes, gauze pads,
hydrogen peroxide, saline, cotton balls, sterile water, etc., aren't covered by
insurance.
"Then there are the nonmedical items you need," Monette says. "For example, lots
and lots of receiving blankets when you have a child who can't swallow, pillows
of various shapes and sizes for support, a backup power source in case the
electricity goes off and the local electric company is slow to respond, and
membership in a local pool or recreation center for aquatic therapies."
'TOO DAMN TIRED'
Hospital staff members offered the Smiths unrealistic advice, urging them to ask
family members — who lived far away and had their own jobs and families — or
nonexistent neighbors to help.
Nurses told Monette, "I've seen parents become advocates for their children."
Monette responded bitterly, "I'm too damn tired to be an advocate. I'm waking
up every day to the possibility of a funeral. I want a normal, healthy child. I
have no background with this, no children with this. I'm not a nurse. I know
nothing except changing diapers and giving bottles."
Although Monette didn't know whom to call, what agencies to contact, or how to
get the desperately needed 24-hour nursing care, she had to start somewhere. If
she and Albert couldn't both keep their jobs, she saw bankruptcy and
destitution in the future.
She began with a legal pad, the Internet and a phone book. "I charted
everything," she says. The hospital charts, which were used as records for the
insurance companies, were constructed with one-hour blocks that nurses would
sign to show that they had been responsible for suctioning Christian's
respiratory secretions and otherwise tending to him during the hour. Monette's
chart showed more detail — for example, that Christian was actually suctioned
several times an hour.
The determined mother contacted the Texas Department of Insurance to appeal her
company's decision. She e-mailed then-Gov. George W. Bush and her state
legislators.
"I said to these people, 'You're wanting to take two honest, hard-working
individuals who are going to have to quit their jobs and go on welfare to get
Medicaid. If the insurance will pay for nursing care, we can pay for the rest
of the bills. Otherwise, you're going to end up supporting a family of four.' I
knew that the best way to help Christian was to help ourselves a little bit."
Soon, a legislator called and asked Monette for the names and numbers at her
insurance company. Shortly thereafter, the company's offer suddenly changed
from providing nursing care for eight hours a day for one week to 24-hour-a-day
coverage for an indefinite period.
HARD DECISIONS
Although the Smiths were able to resume some semblance of a normal life, their
troubles were far from over.
Christian began having trouble with his feedings at about 8 months. Liquid would
come back up from his stomach into his esophagus no matter what his parents did
to prevent this. At the same time, his breathing was weakening, and his heart,
having to do extra work to support his breathing, was dangerously enlarging.
On Sept. 18, at 10 months old, his right lung collapsed, and he nearly died.
Christian survived but his condition remained weak, and doctors advised the
family to take a hard look at the future and what measures they would or
wouldn't take to keep their baby alive through the next crisis.
"It's easy for them to say you should let the child go," Monette says. "It's
different when it's your child. It's not easy to watch a kid gasp for breath.
Christian was still very social, he was starting to babble, and he was moving
his limbs. As long as he was willing to fight, we were willing to help him out
a bit."
Christian started on BiPAP (air given through the nose or mouth) during the
night. He also stayed on continuous oxygen therapy. The Smiths decided they
didn't want their baby to have a tracheostomy (opening in the neck) for
ventilation, and that they wouldn't have Christian resuscitated if he had
another respiratory crisis. But that decision was soon put to the test.
'THIS IS NOT SMA'
Suspicious of the SMA diagnosis, the Smiths had continued to do research and to
compare their son's symptoms and appearance with that of other children with
SMA. Their search landed them in December 2000 in the office of Susan
Iannaccone, a pediatrician at Texas Scottish Rite Hospital for Children in
Dallas, where she co-directs the MDA clinic.
After examining him, Monette recalls, the doctor put her hand on Christian's
leg, looked at his parents and said simply, "This is not SMA."
Monette and Albert were again in shock, but this time there was optimism
underlying their anxiety. Plans were made for a new muscle biopsy, after
routine respiratory tests.
The tests showed that Christian's carbon dioxide levels were much too high, a
sign that his respiratory function was dangerously out of whack. Again, the
child went into respiratory crisis, and was transferred to Children's Medical
Center of Dallas, where his parents were told they had to make a decision.
Should the doctors put a tube down Christian's trachea immediately and start
him on a ventilator? If they didn't, he would die.
"I have to thank that doctor," Monette says of the emergency room physician who
talked to them that day. The doctor said, "I can tell you that you've been
living with this incorrect diagnosis this whole year. Part of the problem here
has been caused by the oxygen he's been on. You don't know what the
possibilities are for him, and he deserves this chance."
Shaken, the Smiths agreed to have Christian intubated and ventilated. His carbon
dioxide quickly returned to normal, and, with his condition stable, the muscle
biopsy was performed — on Dec. 7, a year to the day after his first biopsy in
Austin.
The next evening, Iannaccone telephoned the Smiths and told them the news.
Christian had nemaline myopathy, a muscle disorder with a prognosis at least
potentially better than that with type 1 SMA. The doctor had seen few cases of
this rare disorder but remembered one child in particular, whom she had treated
when at Boston Children's Hospital. Tentatively, Albert Smith asked what had
become of that child. "She's 14 years old and goes to school," Iannaccone
replied.
"We just celebrated and thought that was the most wonderful thing we had ever
heard," says Monette. A week later, Christian underwent surgery.
"We had never wanted to do the trach when we thought it was SMA," Monette says.
"But I went on the Internet and saw children who had trachs and vents who were
sitting up, playing with siblings. Everybody was so upset that he was in the
hospital at Christmastime, but we weren't. We felt like it was our Christmas
present. We were so excited that Christian had hope, something we had never had
before with him. We had something to look forward to now."
Through his state's early intervention program, Christian, now 19 months old, is
getting physical, occupational and speech therapies with oral stimulation to
prepare him for normal eating. He can make noises around his trach, tries to
sing with music and has gained in strength. The Smiths are considering doing
surgery on Christian's feet so he can walk if he gains enough strength for
that.
Christian can now lift his head, almost roll over and work more with his hands.
He's holding his eyes open for longer periods, and his chest cavity has opened
up and widened out. His shoulders are in better alignment, and he can twist his
torso.
Corbin, 4, likes to try to engage his brother in
play. Christian's supply-filled room is often the household's center.
|
Says Monette, "My kid is alive. My child has taught me more in his short
lifetime than I have learned in all of mine. I've never been patient, and now I
am. I used to be very perfectionistic.
"When you have a special needs child, your schedule is not your schedule
anymore. You learn to let the small stuff go. Christian has so much strength
that it gives you strength. You look at everything he has overcome."
THE BEAUTY OF HOLLAND
Monette is fond of a poem that compares having a special needs child with going
to Holland when you expected to go to Italy.
In the poem, she says, "You go to a travel agent and you're all ready to go on a
trip to Italy. You have the brochures, you learn Italian, you've booked a
hotel. But you walk off the plane and you're in Holland. You don't speak the
language, you don't know where to go or what to do. "But over time, you find
that Holland is just as beautiful as Italy." 
|