ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY

A.T. FUNDING CHALLENGE

Helpful resources, solutions exist

by Alyssa Quintero

Technology has solved countless problems, but it hasn't come up with an answer to one of the world's oldest questions: How do I pay for it?

Vast technological advances in computers, augmentative communication devices, environmental control units (ECUs) and other high-tech items have enabled people with neuromuscular diseases to be more independent and more active in virtually every aspect of life.

But how do you benefit from new assistive technology (AT) developments if you can't afford them?

No Easy Answers

AT experts agree that, while technology is moving forward at the speed of light, the funding question is stalled.

"Sometimes getting the money for AT is a whole different ball game," says Katherine Belknap, project director for ABLEDATA. "There really is no easy answer, but we list some issues that people need to look at, and we list several different kinds of organizations by state where people can get referrals or direct [funding] assistance."

ABLEDATA, operated by the federal National Institute on Disability and Rehabilitation Research (NIDRR), provides information about AT products and rehabilitation equipment, and their sources, on its Web site and publications.

"AT is expensive because it has a relatively small market, as opposed to a mass market product," Belknap added. "Generally, the more you can sell, the cheaper you can make it, but AT isn't like that."

David Dikter, executive director of the Assistive Technology Industry Association (ATIA), which represents companies that sell AT, stated, "That's a struggle for our membership. They want people to be able to have access to their technology, but there will be no technology if they give it all away."

The reality is that many products "created and developed to enhance function, create greater independence, and create access to the workplace and learning are not generally funded by any clear means," Dikter added.

If insurance or Medicare doesn't cover the AT you need, Dikter recommends that you contact an AT manufacturer, vendor or reseller, who may know about other "pathways to funding."

"AT manufacturers/vendors are in business to help people; it's their passion," Dikter explained.

Where to Start

MDA provides $2,000 toward the one-time purchase of an alternative augmentative communication (AAC) device when an MDA clinic physician prescribes it.

MDA's loan closets also may have recycled and new computers or communication equipment. Borrowing a device lets you try before you buy, or assists you while you secure funding for your own device.

Medicare and some private insurance policies generally cover the costs of AAC devices. But Medicare or private insurance isn't going to pay for more than one device. Nor will Medicare reimburse for the purchase of integrated AAC devices that feature computer-access capabilities or functions like e-mail, Internet or word processing.

Medicare allows you to rent some equipment, while other equipment must be purchased. For speech-generating devices, Medicare pays 80 percent, and you're responsible for the remaining 20 percent.

States may offer Medicaid waivers to help fund AT; however, Medicaid generally requires recipients to first use other funding sources to obtain needed services. Criteria and eligibility requirements vary from state to state.

Help Where You Live

Your state's federally funded Assistive Technology Act Program is another possible source. These programs, which operate in all states, work to improve access to AT products and services.

"Your first call should be to your state AT program because they can serve as that first line of contact for people looking for AT information," said Nell Bailey, project director for RESNA's (Rehabilitation, Engineering & Assistive Technology Society of North America) Technical Assistance Project, which operates the state AT programs.

These programs are the experts at putting people in touch with AT resources and providing information about local funding sources. They also offer demonstration, loan, recycling/reuse and equipment exchange programs.

"The state AT projects have the greatest, broadest knowledge of AT products, devices and services," said John Moore, assistant director of the Texas Technology Access Program. "They know where all the funding sources are in the state and the suppliers of assistive technology."

The programs provide short-term equipment loans for people who want to try a device, and replacement devices when AT equipment is being repaired. Typically, these loans can be extended on a case-by-case basis.

Some state programs even donate new or used equipment to clients who can't afford to purchase their own, especially low-income people with disabilities.

The recycling/reutilization programs sanitize and refurbish donated equipment that's then donated or sold at an affordable price to clients. Exchange programs help match those who need used equipment with people who have equipment to donate or sell. Some states' AT programs partner with ATMatch.com, a national marketplace that matches AT donors and sellers with buyers.

Sheila Simmons, project coordinator for the Assistive Technology for Kansans Program, explained, "We are here to help people understand AT, so we provide basic access. Individuals should be able to touch equipment and learn more about it."

Often, state AT programs help people identify funding sources for which they qualify but weren't aware of. Staff will evaluate whether a person qualifies for assistance from Vocational Rehabilitation services, state grant programs, including Medicaid waivers, or private organizations.

Financing Fosters Independence

While state AT programs may lend or give you a device, the Alternative Financing Program (AFP) may help you buy one. (For a detailed article, see "Funding Freedom," May-June 2006.)

The AFP grants low-interest loans to people with disabilities, their parents, relatives or advocates in order to finance new or used AT devices or services - including computer hardware and software, AAC devices and ECUs.

People on fixed incomes or those who don't qualify for traditional bank loans may find AFPs more receptive to their applications. For example, many programs work with recipients of Supplemental Security Income (SSI) or Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI). Understandably, the loans are smaller so the borrowers will be able to afford the monthly payments.

AFPs, which operate in 33 states and U.S. territories, make allowances for poor credit, especially if it's related to a person's disability.

Joey Wallace, a public policy analyst and executive director of Virginia's Assistive Technology Loan Fund Authority (ATLFA), explained, "Even people on a fixed income can benefit, and find a way into the system and get things paid for."

Sue Castles, loan program coordinator for the Illinois TechConnect Program, noted, "Everyone's not automatically going to get a loan. But we'll work with you to learn about why a person has a certain credit history. Did they have to file for bankruptcy because of their disability and mounting medical bills? We try to find out those kinds of things before we turn them down."

To help your cause, Andrea Dimond, program director for the Washington Assistive Technology Foundation (WATF), recommends that loan applicants keep detailed financial records, be aware of their finances and provide a detailed budget.

Jason Luciano, director of the Massachusetts AT Loan Program, also noted that a person's credit score improves when he or she makes loan payments on time. Luciano worked with a young man with a disability who applied for a loan with a 0 credit rating. He was granted a loan and made payments on time. Six months later when he applied for a vehicle loan, his credit score had gone up to 700.

Jackie Wilks-Weathers, program director for Georgia's Credit-Able, said the program has given people small loans to help establish their credit, serving as "a track record for a future loan."

Wilks-Weathers added that the AFP evaluates a person's complete financial situation because "the idea is to provide them with a tool to live more independently, not put them into a worse financial situation."

"We're trying to make sure that technology gets into the hands of people who need it, and that they are able to access that through affordable financing," she said.

Combining Sources

If you receive partial AT funding from one source, such as a Medicaid waiver or a private grant, a small, low-interest AFP loan can help close the gap and complete your purchase.

For example, the Washington AT Foundation offers micro loans up to $1,000 to use in conjunction with other forms of assistance.

In addition to its guaranteed loan program, the Pennsylvania Assistive Technology Foundation (PATF) also offers a minigrant/miniloan option. Low-income borrowers may qualify for a 0 percent interest loan under $1,000 and up to a 50 percent grant. The miniloan has a three-year repayment term at $20 a month.

"We want to help people get the AT they need and improve their creditworthiness," said PATF Executive Director Susan Tachau.

Like other AFPs, Tachau explained, PATF also helps people locate other funding sources, and it will explore all possible funding options before giving a minigrant.

Promoting Independent Living

Your local centers for independent living (CILs) have valuable information about AT funding sources in your area. Independent living specialists often work with people with disabilities to secure split funding from more than one source, ensuring that you have a better chance of getting the AT you need.

"We utilize a lot of creative funding sources," said Von Elison, executive director of the Central Washington Disability Resources Center for Independent Living. "There're a lot of creative methods and so many different ways of funding AT, and with patience, it can be done."

Many CILs offer short-term loans and no-cost recycled equipment. They also have equipment exchange programs, which offer items at prices lower than the cost of new items and make backup devices affordable.

"CILs play a tremendous role," said Nanci Lederman, Recycled Equipment Exchange Program (REEP) coordinator for the Three Rivers Center for Independent Living in Pittsburgh. "That's part of our mission."

Still More Sources

If you're employed, check with your state Department of Vocational Rehabilitation to determine what types of AT devices and services qualify for coverage in order to maintain employment.

For veterans, the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs may provide funding for AT.

And, if you're receiving SSI benefits, the Social Security Administration allows recipients to set aside SSI income to be used toward an approved Plan for Achieving Self-Support (PASS) without jeopardizing benefits. A PASS plan can include saving funds to purchase AT devices or services to help reach an occupational or educational goal.

Working the Funding Maze

"Lack of funding remains the greatest barrier to consumer access to AT," public policy analyst Joey Wallace explained. "With all the increased availability of information, device demonstration centers and equipment evaluation opportunities, people with disabilities continue to struggle to find available financial resources."

Notably, inconsistencies among the federal government, states and insurance companies make the financial maze dizzying.

To avoid getting lost, be proactive, creative and resourceful. It also pays to keep detailed notes and records. If you're denied by one funding agency, find out why, and look for another.

If there's a device you need, contact its manufacturers and vendors because they generally have funding departments that can help locate other funding sources, or possibly work out a lease or rental plan. Some manufacturers may even loan AT devices.

Private organizations and AT manufacturers may be able to put you in contact with families who've been successful at locating funding and purchasing similar equipment.

You may have to take the long way through the maze, but do your research and ask questions. They're important keys to gaining access to the AT that you need.


Turning Over a (Digital) Leaf

by Michael P. Murphy

For more than 20 years, I've read with the aid of a page turner, which is basically an easel upon which a book/magazine rests. By pressing a switch, a mechanical arm swings across, presses a lump of putty into the right-hand page, swings back and (hopefully) turns the page.

When a page turner works, it's a miracle. When it doesn't work, it's a source of anger and frustration. If the putty doesn't stick, the page won't turn at all. If the putty sticks too well, the page is torn instead of turned. At times like this, a steady stream of expletives coming from my room informs everyone that my page turner isn't working!

In order to preserve my sanity - not to mention my happy home - I recently took the plunge and tried an electronic book - or e-book. I ended up reading six of them in one month.

Understand, I love technology. Whether it's the ventilator that keeps me breathing, the computer that allows me to work, do research and correspond, or the air conditioning that helps me through the hot, muggy summers, technological tools have made my life as a person with a disability not only possible, but enjoyable.

Nevertheless, I was reluctant to sample digital media. I've loved books all my life - not just reading, but admiring the craftsmanship of leather-bound volumes and the fun (often garish) cover art from pulp paperbacks. And if you're as big a comic book fan as I am, you'll know that the very smell of old newsprint can be downright intoxicating.

E-books have none of these qualities. They do, however, possess one advantage over their paper ancestors:

They work.

Handicapped people have always used new technology to improve their lives, and I hope that this will be no different. Expense should be no great obstacle. Most online retailers sell e-books at prices equal to, or slightly less than, their hard-copy counterparts. For instance, I recently read a nonfiction e-book that sells in bookstores, in hardcover, for around $30, while I only paid $18.

As for the software needed to read on your PC or Palm pilot, many (but not all) retailers provide it free of charge - probably thinking that once you sign up with one of the online e-book services, they'll make more money in the long term by feeding your e-book addiction.

Earlier this year, I let my subscription to Playboy magazine expire, and signed up for the digital version instead. Rather than arrive in my mailbox every month, each issue is now downloaded right onto my computer. It's probably the greatest invention since the Mounds bar.

I'm not about to trash my page turner, mainly because I have several shelves groaning under the weight of unread books and magazines. Also, some rarer and more obscure titles aren't (yet) available electronically. Nevertheless, reading is such a vital source of education, enlightenment and entertainment that it'd be ridiculous not to take advantage of this new medium. After all, it's the content that's important, not the method of conveyance. Enjoy!

Michael P. Murphy, who has spinal muscular atrophy, is the author of two science fiction novels and one mystery/thriller, available in both paperback and e-book format at authorhouse.com. Some of his other favorite e-book sites include ebooks.com, fictionwise.com and ereader.com. For more about e-books, see "Reading Between the (On)Lines".


Technology Changed My Life

by Christamae Zimpel

In 2004, I was referred to the Center for Applied Rehabilitation Technology (CART) in Downey, Calif., by the state Vocational Rehabilitation office as part of my preparation to attend college. Although my college plans didn't work out, my visit to CART opened many doors of independence, encouragement and hope.

I came home with all kinds of ideas that December day, and CART's thorough evaluation justified purchases by Voc Rehab, including WYNN Wizard for reading and writing, SofType 4.2, a trackball mouse and a scanner.

Seeing all the assistive technology (AT) was really encouraging. I found out that, even if I could only move one part of my body, I could still type using an awesome Morse code system. Right now, I don't need this system, but it's a comfort to know that other options are available.

High-Tech Help

Having a deteriorating, progressive disease (congenital muscular dystrophy) takes a lot of freedoms from you. For one thing, long-term intubation from scoliosis surgery and a subsequent trach have damaged my vocal cords. For seven months I had no voice, and when it came back it was very soft. I often couldn't be heard, especially in public areas.

CART outfitted me with a ChatterVox for the day. Throughout the day, no one ever said, "What?" or "I can't hear you" - even in a cafeteria. Later, MDA bought me my own ChatterVox, and my communication and socialization have greatly improved.

At CART I also learned about bookshare.org, which reopened the door of reading to me. It has a whole library of books online so that people who can't manipulate books can still read.

All Through the House

We went to this neat house with tons of high-tech equipment. It was a model home built by the Rancho Los Amigos Foundation with universal design principles and the latest equipment. In the technology room were probably 50 different kinds of telephones - TTY, voice-activated, large buttons, Braille, etc. I tried a simple speakerphone with 10 programmable numbers, but people couldn't hear me on it.

Now I use a headset with a standard phone. California has a program that buys adapted telephones for people with disabilities. This awesome program is paid for by a $1 charge a month on every Californian's phone bill. I think this program should be nationally implemented.

CART also recommended that I get an ECU (environmental control unit). I realized that Voc Rehab probably doesn't consider running a TV part of an education plan, and the $600 cost wasn't within our grasp.

Offhandedly, I mentioned MDA. A little idea light popped into the eyes of the occupational therapist who was escorting me. She said, "I believe we have one of those (ECUs) that MDA donated. MDA told us to give it to someone of our choice who had MD."

Well, right then and there, they chose me! I now use the TASH Relax II ECU for my TV, DVD, CD player and fan. It's so nice to have that little bit of independence.

I learned of many other technologies. One program lets you scan the pages of a textbook onto the computer so you can read it. This program also allows highlighting, text notes, bookmarking, and has options to help those with learning disabilities - which I didn't need.

The house was remarkable. My mom (who has a milder form of CMD and can walk and perform basic physical tasks) was marveling at the adaptive kitchen, with special counters, drawers and appliances. Mom said, "If I had a kitchen like this I could cook independently again." I also remember seeing a machine that fed someone with a push of a button.

Tech for Tomorrow

My trip to CART offered me hope for the future, knowing there's technology to help keep me active. I use SofType, the ECU and a mike every day. Every iota of independence is precious. Without CART I wouldn't have this independence.

CART (www.rancho.org/cart), part of Rancho Los Amigos National Rehabilitation Center, accepts national referrals, which are sometimes paid for by insurance policies or Voc Rehab. CART is everything that a technology center should be - friendly, informative, and promoting hope and independence.

Christamae Zimpel, 21, of Ceres, Calif., likes to read, write poetry, socialize and e-mail. She's involved with disability and Disney groups, and works with the support group Ones Who Care. You can see more about her at www.caringbridge.com/ca/oellacz.


AT Funding Resources

AAC-RERC (Rehabilitation Engineering Research Center)
www.aac-rerc.com/pages/medicare/MCgeneral.htm

ABLEDATA
(800) 227-0216
www.abledata.com

Assistive Technology Industry Association (ATIA)
(877) 687-2842
www.atia.org

ATmatch.com
www.atmatch.com

Bank of America Access Loans
(800) 900-9000
www.bankofamerica.com/vehicle_and_personal_loans

Center for Medicare & Medicaid Services
(800) 633-4227
www.cms.hhs.gov

Digital Credit Union
(800) 328-8797
www.dcu.org/loans_visa/mobility_menu.html

DisabilityInfo.gov (AT resources)
www.disabilityinfo.gov/digov-public/public/DisplayPage.do?parentFolderId=109

Independent Living Research Utilization Directory of Centers
(713) 520-0232
www.ilru.org/html/publications/directory/index.html

Independent Living USA
www.ilusa.com/links/ilcenters.htm

National Council on Independent Living
(202) 207-0334
www.ncil.org

RESNA - National Assistive Technology Technical Assistance Partnership (NATTAP)
(703) 524-6686
www.resna.org/taproject

RESNA - Alternative Financing Technical Assistance Project
(703) 524-6686
www.resna.org/AFTAP

Social Security Administration (PASS)
(800) 772-1213
www.ssa.gov/pubs/11017.html

State Departments of Vocational Rehabilitation
www.jan.wvu.edu/sbses/vocrehab.htm
(Check your telephone directory under "state listings.")

U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs
(800) 827-1000
www.va.gov