Managing Myasthenia
|
Array of Treatments
Means
Myasthenia Gravis Usually Isnt So Grave
|
|
|
| |
Charles
Ranly, whos had MG for eight years, oversees the plantings at
his Texas country club.
Photo by Charlie Bublik |
by Dan Stimson
Charles Ranly is a busy man, but he always takes time to stop and smell
the roses or more accurately, the pansies,
zinnias, begonias and other seasonal flowers at Webb Hill, the 223-acre
country club he owns in Wolf City, Texas.
The club boasts an 18-hole golf course and has over 600 members. Ranly,
68, oversees 12 to 20 employees (depending on the season), hosts golf
tournaments and civic events year-round, and personally attends to the
10,000 or so flowers that decorate the grounds.
But all of that seemed in jeopardy eight years ago, when Ranly experienced
a series of unusual medical problems — first double vision, then
difficulty chewing, swallowing and talking. A visit to Gil Wolfe, co-director
of the MDA clinic at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center
in Dallas, revealed that he had myasthenia gravis (MG) a disease that causes weakness and fatigue, sometimes affecting the
muscles that control breathing.
At first, Ranly recalls, "I got depressed. Im a real strong person
and I couldnt believe this was happening to me." He worried that
he might have to give up the country club. But thanks to medication
and periodic rest breaks, hes kept his
MG in check.
Wolfe is impressed, but not surprised, by Ranlys perseverance. "Taking
care of MG patients is one of the more rewarding things that I do, because
we can really help people," he says. "Its a very treatable
disease."
But that doesnt mean that MG is simple to treat, he admits. There
are many treatments available to people with the disease and finding the right ones for each patient can be a challenge.
The Nerve-Muscle
Connection
MG is an autoimmune disease, meaning that the immune system
turns against the bodys own tissues. In
the case of MG, the immune system targets the connection between nerve
and muscle, or the neuromuscular junction.
The normal sequence of events between nerve impulse and muscle contraction
takes about a thousandth of a second. Nerve cells release a chemical
called acetylcholine (ACh), which attaches to a docking site
on muscle cells, called the ACh receptor. Once its captured
ACh, the receptor actually a pore in the muscle cell twists open, causing an inward flux of electrical current that triggers
muscle contraction. These events are terminated (at least in part) by acetylcholinesterase, an enzyme that breaks down ACh in the space
between the nerve ending and the muscle cell surface.
 |
|
Myasthenia
gravis occurs when the immune system makes antibodies that destroy
the ACh receptor (AChR), a docking site for the nerve chemical
acetylcholine (ACh). Some treatments block acetylcholinesterase
(AChE), an enzyme that breaks down ACh, while others target the
immune system. |
|
In most cases of MG, the immune system makes antibodies that recognize
the ACh receptor. The antibodies, Y-shaped missiles that normally attack
bacteria and viruses, destroy many of the ACh receptors on muscle. Consequently,
the muscles response to repeated nerve
stimulation declines with time, causing weakness and fatigue.
Of course, none of this was known in the late 19th century, when MG
was first described in detail. Understandably, the outlook for patients
was grim; in fact, the name of the disease, which literally means "grave
muscular weakness," was chosen to
emphasize its severe, often fatal course. Even in the early 20th century,
many people with MG lost strength rapidly within a year or two of diagnosis,
and they ultimately died of respiratory failure.
In the 1930s, the role of ACh at the neuromuscular junction was discovered,
and soon, cholinesterase inhibitors drugs that block the breakdown
of ACh by acetylcholinesterase became
a standard treatment for MG. In the 1960s, researchers discovered the
autoimmune nature of MG, and began attacking the disease at its roots
using immunosuppressant drugs.
Today, thanks to these treatments and others, its
estimated that the mortality rate of MG is less than 5 percent.
Is It Really MG?
Experts say the first step toward getting effective treatment for MG
is an accurate diagnosis.
Double vision and droopy eyelids might lead a physician to suspect
MG. Weakness of the extraocular muscles, those that control movement
of the eyes and eyelids, is conspicuously absent in many neuromuscular
diseases, but its a common and early symptom
of MG.
For about 15 percent of people with MG, the disease remains exclusively
"ocular" for its entire course, but for most people, it eventually
becomes "generalized," involving
voluntary muscles throughout the body. If left untreated, weakness often
spreads from the extraocular muscles to the rest of the face (including
the jaw, throat, and tongue), then to the limbs and trunk, and finally
to the respiratory muscles.
Weakness that fluctuates during the day and over longer periods, from
months to years, is another hallmark of MG. But other diseases can cause
similar symptoms, and to the untrained eye, some of these can look a
lot like MG.
The most reliable indicator of MG is a blood test that reveals antibodies
to the ACh receptor, says Daniel Drachman, director of the MDA clinic
at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore.
But that test isnt foolproof, Drachman points out. "Weve known
for a long time that people with mild MG may have no ACh receptor antibodies,
and that as many as 15 percent with generalized MG dont have the antibodies," Drachman admits.
A 2001 study showed that many of these seronegative MG patients
have antibodies to MuSK, a protein that helps organize ACh receptors
on the muscle cell surface. Unfortunately, blood tests for detecting
the MuSK antibodies arent yet commercially
available.
If the blood test for ACh receptor antibodies is negative, the next
step is usually electromyography (EMG), which involves using
electrodes to measure a muscles response
to nerve impulses. Edrophonium (Tensilon), a fast-acting cholinesterase
inhibitor, might be given as a test to temporarily improve neuromuscular
transmission.
Finally, "Its key to distinguish MG from congenital myasthenic
syndromes," Drachman says. These diseases related to but
different from MG are caused by genetic defects in the ACh receptor
and other components of the neuromuscular junction, and thus can share
symptoms with MG. Some even respond well to cholinesterase inhibitors,
but they arent treatable with immunosuppressant
drugs.
A family history of myasthenic symptoms, childhood onset and a seronegative
blood test for MG generally favor a diagnosis of CMS.
The Path to Treatment
Once a diagnosis of MG is established, both doctor and patient face
many decisions regarding treatment. Most of the available medications
and procedures have side effects, from mood changes to gastrointestinal
problems, and a few have been linked to more serious ailments, including
osteoporosis and kidney damage.
The balance between risk and benefit must be weighed separately for
each patient, Wolfe says.
"Theres really not a blanket approach to treating MG," he
explains. "You have to individualize therapy by factoring in a
variety of issues, including the severity of the disease and other conditions
present in the medical history."
In addition, he says, "you have to factor in the patients perspective
on their disease on how well theyre functioning now and what things
theyd like to be able to do better." For example, someone who
has a physically demanding career might prefer an aggressive, risky
treatment over a less risky, slower-acting treatment; someone whos
retired might prefer the opposite.
Donald Sanders, director of the MDA clinic at Duke University in Durham,
N.C., says that, all things considered, cholinesterase inhibitors are
usually the first-line treatment for MG. These drugs, which include
pyridostigmine (Mestinon) and neostigmine (Prostigmin), can alleviate
symptoms within minutes, and have no major side effects, he points out.
"Occasionally, they produce enough improvement that other treatments
arent necessary, particularly in patients with mild disease. But that
is the exception rather than the rule," he says.
While cholinesterase inhibitors boost the amount of ACh that reaches
muscle, they dont counter the immune systems
assault on the ACh receptor. Thus, long-term treatment of MG usually
requires immunosuppression.
Immunosuppressant Drugs
Drachman, whos been practicing medicine
for more than 40 years, remembers what the prognosis of MG was like
before scientists understood its autoimmune nature.
In the 1950s, he says, "It was really bad. Many of these people
were on respirators, they had feeding tubes. They were severely impaired
or theyd die." He remembers one patient
who was kept alive with an iron lung.
"The development of a variety of effective immunosuppressant
drugs and the knowledge of how to use them both individually and in
combination has been crucial to treating MG," he says.
Among these drugs, corticosteroid hormones and azathioprine
(Imuran) are the most widely used.
Corticosteroids (which include prednisone) are relatively inexpensive
and tend to act fast, producing improvement within weeks. But when taken
over the long term, they can have many side effects, including weight
gain, high blood pressure, cataracts, osteoporosis, and a blunting of
mood and memory.
"The side effects of corticosteroids are a major limiting factor,
but they can be dealt with in most patients," says Sanders, noting for example, that osteoporosis can be prevented
with bisphosphonate drugs. Also, he says, corticosteroids can be used
to induce rapid improvement, and then gradually tapered off and supplemented
with other immunosuppressants.
"The main advantage [of Imuran] is that, except for uncommon side
effects, it doesnt produce any long-term problems," he says. "The
biggest limitation is that it takes a long time to work [three to six
months]."
Both Sanders and Drachman have been investigating the possibility of
treating MG with mycophenylate mofetil (CellCept), a drug originally
developed to prevent rejection of transplanted organs. In pilot studies,
about two-thirds of MG patients gained strength or were able to reduce
their need for prednisone after taking CellCept for several months.
Sanders is now heading a multicenter, three-year trial comparing CellCept
plus prednisone to prednisone alone in MG.
Other Options
Besides this arsenal of drugs, surgeries and other procedures are often
successful in treating MG.
Thymectomy, the removal of an immune system gland called the
thymus, is the oldest, first tried in 1913. From fetal development through
childhood, the thymus produces immune cells called T-cells, but at puberty
the gland starts to degenerate. About 15 percent of people with MG have
a thymic tumor, called a thymoma, and another 65 percent have abnormal
thymic tissue; theres evidence that these
abnormalities might trigger the production of antibodies to the ACh
receptor.
Thymectomy is necessary for treating thymoma, and often recommended
for generalized MG.
"Evidence that it works [for MG] is more historical rather
than scientific," Sanders says. "Its felt to be the only
therapy capable of inducing a long-term drug-free remission, but there
has never been a controlled study of it."
Wolfe plans to change that. He and colleagues are setting up a trial
of MG patients (without thymoma) in which half will receive thymectomy
and corticosteroids, while the other half will receive corticosteroids
alone. The studys main goal is to determine
what effect thymectomy has on corticosteroid requirements over the next
few years.
Two other procedures bring about fast, but short-lived relief from
MG, and thus are used mostly for myasthenic crisis, a rapid worsening
of symptoms that can culminate in respiratory distress. (See "Myasthenic
Crisis.")
Plasmapheresis, also called plasma exchange, was developed
by MDA-funded researchers in the 1970s. It involves the use of an intravenous
line to filter the blood and remove ACh receptor antibodies.
Intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG) therapy is essentially an
injection of nonspecific antibody (immunoglobulin). Recent studies suggest
that it works by dialing down the immune systems
production of its own antibodies, much like the negative feedback circuit
that tells the thermostat to stop pumping out heat once your house is
warm.
The Big Picture
None of these treatments is a cure for MG, but all of them used alone
or in combination can serve as powerful
tools for managing the disease.
"A diagnosis of MG probably means life-long treatment for most
people," Drachman says. "It entails a big commitment on the
part of the doctor and the patient to take care of it, follow it and
not let it go."
In very rare cases, MG is "refractory" or resistant to treatment
(see "Refractory MG," below). But for most people, the disease
isnt nearly as grave as the name implies.
 |
|
Ranly
and his wife, Shirley, at the country club they own |
|
Just ask Charles Ranly.
Since his diagnosis, Ranly has taken Mestinon, Imuran and prednisone.
Hes seen his energy go down and his weight go up. Hes
had two myasthenic crises and two corresponding sessions of plasmapheresis.
He used to work at his country club seven days a week, six to eight
hours a day; MG has forced him to cut his schedule in half. He used
to play golf at a professional level, and MG has put an end to his game
altogether. But it hasnt stopped him from
enjoying life.
"Now I get my enjoyment from visiting with my [country
club] members and planting flower beds," he says. "The
only thing I have to do is take my medication, slow down and rest properly.
"Having a facility like this and making it work, Im living the
American dream."
Myasthenic
Crisis: Be Alert, Not Afraid |
| |
Judy Walsh will be the first person to tell you that MG
can be unpredictable, with a potential for myasthenic crisis a rapid worsening of symptoms
that can lead to respiratory failure.
Shell also tell you that she doesnt
let that unpredictability dominate her life.
Walsh, 46, lives in Tiverton, R.I., and is a pediatric
psychotherapist. About nine years ago, she noticed that
the muscles in her neck felt weak, and eventually, she started
having problems with swallowing and speech. At work, it
became difficult for her to talk with patients.
| |
 |
|
Judy Walsh (lower
right) and family |
In 1996, after a referral to the MDA clinic at Rhode Island
Hospital in Providence, she was found to have MG. She was
treated with a thymectomy and put on Mestinon and prednisone.
"Within a year," she says, "I was
pretty stable and back at work full time. I would have periods
of exacerbation and Id go in for plasmapheresis or IVIG,
but I went on pretty well for a while."
When she had one of those exacerbations in spring 1999,
she set up an appointment for IVIG a week later.
Although she didnt know it at the time, she was on a downward
spiral toward a severe myasthenic crisis. Often, its possible
to identify a specific trigger for myasthenic crisis, such
as a respiratory infection, a traumatic injury or stress,
but Walsh doesnt remember
one.
"When I got to the hospital, I put on my pajamas
and got into bed. And in a matter of hours, I couldnt move
my arms or legs," she says. "I thought I was dying."
Indeed, she came close. She stopped breathing, and was
put on a respirator and a feeding tube for four weeks, while
doctors pumped her with prednisone and Imuran. She lost
30 pounds, and had to stay in the hospitals
intensive care unit for a month.
When she left the hospital, her swallowing problems persisted,
so she continued to rely on the feeding tube for several
months. She returned to the hospital for plasmapheresis
once a week.
With continued plasmapheresis (now, she gets it about once
every three months), and a familiar litany of drugs (Mestinon,
prednisone and Imuran), Walshs MG has stabilized again.
Shes back at her office three days a week and "has
an active life," she says.
She doesnt dwell on the possibility of another myasthenic
crisis, but shes prepared for it. Shes
become educated about MG, maintains a good rapport with
her doctors, and knows to seek medical attention at the
first signs of increased weakness.
"[Myasthenic crisis] can be frightening,"
she says. "But once you realize you can get better,
you get back into gear and take charge of your life again." |
|
|
Refractory
MG Meets Its Match? |
| |
A few years
ago, if someone had tried to tell Lynn Castro that MG was
a treatable disease, she might have responded by saying
something unladylike.
After a car accident in 1998,
Castro gradually recovered from her injuries, but began
having episodes of labored breathing. A visit to the University
of Alabama at Birmingham Hospital, near her home in Vestavia
Hills, Ala., revealed that she had MG.
 |
|
Lynn
Castro |
|
Immediately after the diagnosis,
she started taking Mestinon and getting regular sessions
of plasmapheresis. (She was already taking prednisone for
lupus erythematosus, an autoimmune disease frequently associated
with MG.)
Despite those measures, she
continued to have problems. At home, she used a BiPAP (a
type of ventilator) to support her breathing while she slept.
She couldnt climb the stairs, and during meals, she sometimes
stopped eating because she didnt have the energy to continue.
In 1999, she was hospitalized
several times for myasthenic crises. She was given a thymectomy
and IVIG, but to no avail.
"I still kept having crises," Castro, 38, recalls.
"I was going in and out of the hospital every other
month, getting intubated each time." She was told that,
one day, she wasnt going to
make it to the hospital on time.
Then, in early 2000, her doctors learned that Daniel Drachman,
director of the MDA clinic at Johns Hopkins University in
Baltimore, was testing a new treatment for refractory MG
MG that doesnt respond to
conventional treatments.
Drachmans treatment involved a high-dose, intravenous
infusion of cyclophosphamide (Cytoxan), a drug traditionally
used to treat cancers of the immune system. The procedure,
given over four days, is believed to destroy mature immune
cells but spare their progenitors in bone marrow. Drachman
hoped that it might be used to "reboot" the immune systems of people with refractory MG.
"We knew it was a drastic approach, but since nothing
else was working, my husband and I felt like we didnt have
any alternative," Castro
says.
So, in March 2000, she traveled to Baltimore, where she
spent five days getting the treatment at Hopkins and another
five weeks in a rented apartment, being monitored daily
at Johns Hopkins, with frequent visits from her family.
Fast-forward to the present, and she seems to be in complete
remission. "I can do so much now that I couldnt do
before," she says. "I can go on walks, use exercise
machines; Ive even started playing basketball with my daughter
again." She had one crisis soon after the treatment,
but hasnt had any since.
Three other people with refractory MG have experienced
equally spectacular results. (For more information, see
"Research
Updates," Quest, December
2002.)
Is it a cure?
"Its too early to tell," Drachman says. "The
patients treated with the procedure are doing well, but
they still have [ACh receptor] antibodies" a sign that the underlying disease is still there. In any
case, he emphasizes, since the treatment carries risks of
infection and hemorrhage, its use will probably stay limited
to refractory MG.
"For me," Castro says, "it has been [a cure].
According to the antibody levels, I still have the disease
but I dont have any symptoms. Its not even a part of
my life anymore." |
|
|
|